30 July 2009

The Ethical Dilemma in Long Term Care

In an ideal world our aging family members would have the opportunity to ease into long term medical care without conflict. Unfortunately, we are far from an ideal world! Our family members encounter ethical problems throughout their healthcare experience. As individuals they seek autonomy; as consumers they desire high quality of care; as caregivers they utilize superlative nurturing for their loved ones; and as people they yearn for freedom from the pain and suffering of health complications. Considering patients and their families may desire these aspects, I would like to discuss some obstacles to autonomy, quality of care, and freedom from suffering.

First, let’s look at autonomy. One consideration here is the ability to make decisions. Does the patient still have the capacity to make decisions regarding their care? As stated by Goodwin et. al., the Veterans Health Administration maintains that a person may be deemed to have decision making ability if they meet the following criteria:

  • The ability to understand the information presented
  • The ability to appreciate the consequences of acting (or not acting) on that information with reference to one’s own values and goals
  • The ability to understand that choices are being offered and to deliberate among the choices
  • The ability to make a consistent or stable choice which is not revoked or altered capriciously
  • The ability to communicate that choice

There is a responsibility that comes with the ability to make decisions, both of the patient and of the caregiver. For the caregiver, “providing the best care requires choosing among conflicting responsibilities, values, and principles” (“Ethical and Legal…”). Thus, decisions regarding care should reflect the values and principles of the patient.

In the event a patient requires admission into a long term care facility, “the crucial ethical question is whether the older adult is capable of making an informed decision about where to live” (“Ethical and Legal…”). The patient’s autonomy should still be respected and measures should be taken to accommodate their lifestyle. One way for the patient to ensure continued autonomy (if they maintain decision making ability) in a long term care facility is through an advanced directive. An advanced directive can be a living will, power of attorney or designation of a healthcare surrogate. These early decisions are “personal choices about life and death [that] reflect a unique person’s autonomy from family and institutional pressures” (Roth). When the time comes to exercise an advanced directive, I would recommend utilizing a social worker, a chaplain, the treating physician, the facility nurses, and – of course – the family. Advanced directives are an easy way for patients to ensure their long term care treatment corresponds to their values and principles.

Next, let’s discuss quality of care. When a person enters the long term care system, they may not be able to define quality of care, but that doesn’t mean they are unaware of what it is. All patients understand the level of care they wish to receive and whether or not they are receiving it. For example, patients receiving home health care may be given inadequate care based on their residence location, the total care required, and the level of care required (“Long Term Care…”). Current trends in society, however, advocate for quality of care in long term care institutions; as well as steering away from the depiction of abuse and neglect in long term care facilities. According to Pratt, it is the responsibility of the facility’s governing body to “ensure that the organization’s customers (patients, residents, clients) receive care of the highest possible quality and are treated with dignity and respect” (360). In my opinion, if a patient or family members has grounded suspicions that they’re being neglected or abused, they should contact a social worker or utilize the ethics committee (if one is available). It should be recognized that a high quality of care delivered in a long term care facility may mean a different level of care for each patient.

One aspect of a high quality of care is freedom from the pain and suffering associated with health complications. “Suffering may refer to physical, emotional, or spiritual symptoms” (Goodwin). As people, it is natural that we wish to avoid pain and suffering. Pain, however, can be a common symptom experienced during critical health situations. Generally, pain can be controlled through medications. But what about suffering? How can caretakers ease the emotional and spiritual suffering of the patient and their family members? I think long term care institutions can accomplish this by holding family sessions with an interdisciplinary care team, and inviting chaplains or personal spiritual counselors to visit patients. Also, delivering a high quality of care – which may eventually include comfort measures – shows the patient and their family that they and their values will be treated with respect. Another issue evolves when the caretakers became like family to the patients. These caretakers may be nurses or non-licensed healthcare professionals. In this case, Goodwin et. al., recommends utilizing the care perspective, which is: “an emerging ethical perspective that provides a useful context for describing these complex caregiver/patient issues.” I have seen nurses who have cared for patients for years help feed them or even rub their feet to deliver a high quality of care!

Ethical issues constantly arise in healthcare. Patients in the long term care system may have goals such as maintaining autonomy, receiving a high quality of care and avoiding pain and suffering. Obstacles to these goals include the patient’s decision making capacity, the lack of advanced directives which leads to interruptions in the plan of care, and finally, their lifestyle trends and the ability of the institution to accommodate those requests. All caretakers should be patient advocates and respect the decisions and values of the patient. In long term care, I believe there is nothing more important than advanced directives!

“Ethical and Legal Issues.” Aging in the Know. 25 February 2005. The American Geriatrics Society. 29 July 2009, http://www.healthinaging.org/agingintheknow/chapters_ch_trial.asp?ch=4.

Goodwin, M., Albert, M., et. al. “Ethical Issues in Long Term Care.” The Verterans Health Administration Bioethics Committee. 29 July 2009, http://www.ethics.va.gov/docs/bkissues/Challenges-and-Change_Ethical_Issues_in_Long-Term_Care.pdf

“Long Term Care and Extended Care Facilities.” Geriatrics and Ethics. The University of Miami. 29 July 2009, http://www6.miami.edu/ethics/geriatrics/geriatrics_ecf.html

Pratt, John. Long-Term Care: Managing Across the Continuum. 2nd ed. Boston: Jones and Bartlett, 2004.

Roth, Mary. “Ethics in Long Term Care.” Sacred Heart Hospital. 29 July 2009, http://www.aafp.org/online/etc/medialib/aafp_org/documents/cme/courses/conf/assembly/lectures/ethics.Par.0001.File.tmp/assemblylecture_015slides.pdf

16 July 2009

Multicultural Long Term Care

Recognizing that the United States is a culturally diverse nation, I have made it a personal goal of mine to help professionals in the medical field learn about and practice multicultural healthcare techniques. I foster this environment of diversity education at my current job; and have hopes of impacting a more global healthcare field in the future.

As long term healthcare becomes more individualized, it is necessary to identify and respect patients’ diverse cultural beliefs. Cultural values and behaviours are just as important in the treatment plan as a patient’s medical condition. According to Pratt, “the long-term care system should be capable of recognizing these differences and at least attempting to accommodate them” (39). Creating an environment that can accommodate diverse cultures in both the healthcare professionals and the patients may prove difficult, but the experiences each group has will help - I think - to improve the long term care system.

So why is multicultural long term healthcare so important? Well, Rexroth and Davidhizar believe “lack of acceptance of the patient or co-workers can lead to intolerance, disharmony, and hostility in the workplace” (297). In other words, the daily grind would be resentful and prejudicial. Long term care employees advocate not only for the cultivation of a collective environment, but also the preservation of individual’s lifestyles. It is my belief that each culture should be represented and valued. Otherwise the person may feel alienated from the group and the treatment. A person who has no faith in their treatment plan has not been adequately involved in the construction of that plan and holds no confidence in its success – especially if that treatment plan contains no essence of their culture. According to Navarrete-Vivero and Jenkins, exclusion from the social environment upsets the developmental process (14). Promoting cultural identity is one way to help people in long term care heal. Long term care encourages multiculturalism through tailored diets and supporting visitation to religious venues.

Conversely, cultural values are not always a positive influence on healthcare. Diverse cultural aspects also play a part in determining the health co-morbidities that a person can have. For example, Ashkenazi Jews have a more probability of coronary artery disease and hyperlipidemia. American Indians are prone to diabetes and being overweight because of ancient food habits. In Yemen, gat parties (gat is a tobacco-like plant) are centered around chewing it socially, which causes them to contract oral cancers and oral diseases. These are aspects of special cultures that long term healthcare employees should be aware of and advocate to cure. Similarly, the treatment plan the healthcare professional implements should be defined from the culture of the patient. This will create more participation and meaning for the patient.

Rextroth, Roberta, and Davidhizar, Ruth. (2003). Caring: Utilizing the Watson Theory to Transcend Culture. The Health Care Manager, 22 (4), 295-304.

Pratt, John. Long-Term Care: Managing Across the Continuum. 2nd ed. Boston: Jones and Bartlett, 2004.

Navarrete-Vivero, Veronica, and Jenkins, Sharon. (1999). Existential Hazards of the Multicultural Individual: Defining and Understanding "Cultural Homelessness." Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology, 5 (1), 6-26.